Category design means defining a new market problem, naming it, and getting buyers, press and investors to judge every competitor by your definition. When it works, the company that defines the category gets most of the category’s value. The best-known figure is Play Bigger’s: in a sample of tech companies, “category kings” held about 76% of their category’s market cap. That number comes from the consultancy’s own research, not from independent academic work. The method has three parts: name a problem buyers already feel but have no word for, publish a point of view that makes the old way look outdated, and align the product, the company and the message behind it. It is not a shortcut to winning. Most pioneers lose to better-run followers.
Where does the 76% figure come from, and how much should you trust it?
The figure comes from Play Bigger, the firm whose founders wrote the 2016 book of the same name. In a Stanford eCorner talk, co-founder Al Ramadan described it as the firm’s own analysis of public tech companies. You will often see it credited to a 2024 NBER paper. That attribution is wrong. No such NBER study is the source.
Use the number as a sign that category value is concentrated, not as a forecast for your company. The sample only includes companies that survived and went public. The startups that tried to create a category and failed are not in the data.
Does being first to a category actually win?
Usually not on its own. Golder and Tellis studied about 500 brands across 50 product categories in their Journal of Marketing Research paper, “Pioneer Advantage: Marketing Logic or Marketing Legend?”. They found that nearly half of market leaders were not the pioneers, and that pioneers’ share advantage shrinks over time.
Later strategy research helps explain why. Suarez, Grodal and Gotsopoulos show in Strategic Management Journal (2015) that the best time to enter opens when buyers settle on a shared category label. It closes when the industry settles on a dominant product design. If you name the category before buyers have a reason to care, rivals profit from your education spend. If you name it after the design has settled, nobody listens. Category design is mostly about getting that timing right.
What does category design look like in a real company?
DoorDash is the cleanest example. It began in 2013 as PaloAltoDelivery.com. Its main idea was that food delivery is a three-sided marketplace: diners, Dashers (its couriers) and restaurants each need a reason to stay. That idea shaped its operations, especially an early focus on suburbs that rivals had underserved. DoorDash’s S-1 filing with the SEC cites Edison Trends data. It shows US share rising from about 17% in January 2018 to about 50% by October 2020, against 26% for Uber Eats and 16% for Grubhub. The IPO was in December 2020, not 2024 as is often repeated.
Keurig is the other common example, and it is often told backwards. Its first brewers in 1998 were built for offices, where one machine could use up a large volume of high-margin K-Cups every day. Home brewers came around 2004, once the pod system had proven itself. Keurig did not start in homes. It used offices to fund the category. A JAB-led investor group bought Keurig Green Mountain for $13.9 billion in 2016.
Tesla is usually credited with turning EVs from a compromise into an aspiration. A common claim says batteries crossed $100/kWh in 2024. Based on US Department of Energy estimates, that is not accurate. The DOE puts 2023 light-duty pack costs at about $139/kWh of usable energy, down roughly 90% from 2008. Tesla built the category story before the costs justified it, and the falling costs made the story stick.
How do you run it, step by step?
- Name the problem, not the product. Write one sentence describing the cost buyers already pay under the old way. If customers don’t recognise it when they read it back, you have a feature, not a category.
- Write the point of view. Cover the old way, the new way, why now, and what changes for the buyer. Keep it to one page. Sales, product and hiring should all be able to quote it.
- Choose a category name buyers would search for. Test it in sales calls before you put it on the website. If prospects reword it every time, the name won’t spread.
- Align the company. The roadmap, pricing and sales qualification should all reflect the point of view. A category story that only marketing tells reads as a slogan.
- Launch it as one event. Concentrate the story into a single moment, such as a launch, a report or a conference keynote, rather than spreading it thinly across a year.
Where does video fit, and what goes wrong?
From the production side, the point-of-view film is usually the asset that carries a category launch. It runs two to four minutes and shows the problem before the product. The most common failure is a brief that starts as “explain the problem” and gets revised into a feature tour. The film then looks like every competitor’s demo, and the category idea disappears.
Budgets depend mostly on whether you need real customers on camera, the number of locations, and the amount of animation. Interview-led films with one or two shoot days usually cost low-to-mid five figures. Productions with multiple locations and heavy motion graphics cost considerably more. Script approval takes longer than the shoot. Expect several rounds of approval with leadership, because the film forces the company to commit to its point of view in writing, often for the first time.
Cut the long film into short clips, one per claim in the point of view, and give them to sales before the launch date. Category stories that only exist on the homepage don’t spread. They spread when salespeople repeat them on calls.
What are the common failure modes?
| Failure | What it looks like | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Too narrow | A category with no realistic path to a large addressable market | Size the market from the bottom up before naming it |
| Too early | You fund buyer education and a follower captures the demand | Launch when buyers already feel the problem |
| Narrative drift | Product and sales go back to comparing features | Review messaging against the point of view every quarter |
| Label without substance | A new name for an existing product | Change the product or pricing, not only the copy |
Start with the problem sentence. Test it in ten customer conversations this month. Only write the point of view and brief any creative once buyers start repeating it back to you unprompted.





